Kevin Hart’s media company will have to defend its case in public after a California judge rejected its attempt to settle the dispute behind closed doors.
On Wednesday, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge ruled that Hartbeat cannot move its lawsuit against two former workers to arbitration, according to court documents obtained by TMZ. Because of that decision, all filings and hearings will now be part of the public record.
At the heart of the case are Eric Eddings and Lesley Gwam. Eddings joined Hartbeat in 2022 and Gwam followed in 2023. Hartbeat accuses them of taking confidential details from the company’s podcast unit and using them to build a competing podcast business. The court papers allege the two used that information to prepare a pitch deck aimed at raising millions for their new company. Hartbeat is asking the court to stop them from launching it.
The company argued the employees had signed contracts requiring disputes to be settled through arbitration, a process that happens away from public view. The judge disagreed, finding that Eddings and Gwam showed the arbitration terms were “unconscionable” and could not be enforced. The request was denied.
Eddings and Gwam reject the allegations. They maintain they did not use any Hartbeat information and note they both had podcast industry experience before joining the company.
For Hartbeat, the ruling means the case will no longer be shielded from public scrutiny. For the former employees, it gives them a chance to respond openly in court.
Hartbeat was co-founded by Kevin Hart and produces films, television shows, and podcasts. The lawsuit is ongoing.
